Rogue One: A Star Wars Story Review

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story Review

The first ever standalone Star Wars movie, Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, debuted on December 16th, and with it comes a unique set of circumstances. At long last, the story of how the Rebellion came into possession of the Death Star plans has come into the canon of Star Wars‘ sometimes daunting mythology, and the revelation of this is unlike anything we’ve seen before on screen from a galaxy far, far away. The ramifications this film will have on future Star Wars storytelling will be intricate and, most likely, long lasting.

This film sets itself from all previous incarnations of the Star Wars saga in beautiful and paradoxical rhythms. It’s equal parts familiar and beautifully unorthodox. The much-ballyhooed absence of an opening crawl, for example, sets the tone. The film starts with a jolt, as the audience realizes two things instantly: 1) “A long time ago …” is present, but the aforementioned crawl is gone, and 2) the film starts on a planet, and not in the depths of space. Familiar, yet different.

It doesn’t stop there either. Each time a new planet is introduced, it’s actually introduced. Text placed on screen (save for one significant planet-longtime Star Wars fans will note the ominous nature of this), informs the viewer the name of the new locale, which is unique to the franchise. A casual fan may not think twice, but seasoned veterans may be temporarily disenfranchised, and might wonder, “What is going on here?” The answer is a bold, creative, unorthodox (for this franchise) way of telling a Star Wars story. The beats and archetypes of what we are used to are off in the distance, and we are left with a revolutionary new way to tell a Star Wars story onscreen.

The director, Gareth Edwards, provides texture and grittiness in a Star Wars film that gives the mythology a layered feel. Everything feels substantial and significant. You really believe that what happens on screen matters to more than a handful of characters. The ominous threat of the burgeoning Death Star’s secret weapon feels authentic and accentuates the cost both audiences and characters on screen feel. There is weight here that creates a dynamic sense of verisimilitude, and it’s more refreshing than I expected or thought I wanted.

The cast also rises to the occasion, with Oscar winner Felicity Jones taking the lead as sometimes-reluctant freedom fighter, Jyn Erso. Rounding out the ensemble are Diego Luna (Cassian Andor), Mads Mikkelson (Galen Erso), Donnie Yen (Chirrut Imwe), Riz Ahmed (Bodhi Rook), Forest Whitaker (Saw Gerrera), Ben Mendelsohn (Orson Krennic), Alan Tudyk (K-2SO0, Jiang Wen (Baze Malbus). If these characters don’t sound familiar, that’s because all of them (save for Saw Gerrera, who appeared in the animated Star Wars: The Clone Wars) are new to the Star Wars universe. This effect is masterful too; as audiences get to know this new collection of heroes, so to do the characters on-screen attempt to get to know one another and work together, despite seemingly insurmountable odds. The Empire is no joke.

Neither is the juggernaut that is the Star Wars franchise. The Force Awakens certainly featured many new characters, but with a safety net including the original cast, there was not much of a financial risk (the monstrous haul of over two billion dollars worldwide proved that). However, Rogue One features no discernible member of the Skywalker family or Jedi, hence the potential for less than diminishing returns. Plus, the tone is notably different. Never has the war in Star Wars felt more authentic or genuine.

The one thing it does have in common with the other entries in the franchise, however, is perfect casting. The chemistry between Jyn Erso and Cassian Andor is tenuous, as is the stability in the galaxy, and the two of them, along with a bickering Rebellion, must bridge their gaps in philosophy and loyalty, in order to take on the stranglehold the Imperial forces have on the galaxy. It works beautifully, as do the cameos and the big screen return of Darth Vader (blissfully voiced once again by the great James Earl Jones). Vader is used sparingly and effectively, especially in the frenetic finale. If you forgot why Vader was frightening when you were younger, Rogue One brings it back in extraordinary fashion.

Rogue One also features the theme of hope, which is synonymous with the Star Wars franchise. There is beauty in the ugliness of war, and it’s because of hope. The hope lies in a system of belief that there can be a better tomorrow and that this can only be accomplished through teamwork and diversity. We are more alike than we are different, and Edwards balances this with the looming threat of conflict in the persona of the Empire and its war machine.

There is a disquieting lack of gender representation (an alarming 17% of women included) in the movie, however. This is somewhat surprising, considering The Force Awakens. Jyn Erso, save for a few powerful moments, is not given much to do, and Rogue One would have benefitted from her being more fleshed out. She is instrumental to the film, and her contribution to the success of the Rebellion is indispensable. Let’s hope we get to see more of her in future storylines, because she is a central figure in the timeline.

Despite this, Rogue One is a powerful film, and a fascinating variation on Star Wars storytelling. The question I’ve been asked most frequently since Rogue One came out is, “Is it better than The Force Awakens?” That’s a fair question and one that inspires engaging discourse. For me, however, I think the better question is what will Rogue One do for the future of Star Wars? It’s so different, in the best way possible, and while I’m not sure it has the same rewatchability factor that the previous seven films do, that isn’t necessarily a bad thing. It’s much heavier than the episodic films, presents a much more discernibly fractured universe, and asks much tougher questions.

4 1/2 out of 5

Look for a much more in-depth analysis from Coffee With Kenobi in the near future, and be sure to check out our immediate pre and post thoughts on Rogue One here.

Be sure to share your thoughts on Rogue One in the comment section below.


Powered by
Please follow and like us:


  1. laurastrachan
    December 21, 2016 at 16:13 Reply

    Just took my 6 and 7 year old to watch this for a Christmas treat. Oh my Disney, this is nothing like the entertaining family friendly films of my childhood. A very dark film that killed off promising characters that had more to give. A better choice would’ve been to take kids to watch a documentary about Aleppo. Story fits in well with whole Starwars narrative though.

  2. Melinda
    December 24, 2016 at 13:26 Reply

    I’ve seen “Rogue One” three times already, and like it more and more with each viewing! (To give you a starting point, I was enthralled with the first viewing. 😉 ) It was a bit of a bummer not to have an opening crawl, but this was one Star Wars film that really didn’t need one (considering we all knew that RO would lead directly into “A New Hope”). Admittedly, I was not a big fan of the planet identifiers appearing in the lower corner when we were introduced to said new planets. I found that distracting — much akin to the station identifiers that appear in the corners of one’s television screen (as if you don’t know what channel you’re watching!). 🙁 I don’t think they added anything. In previous instances, we have learned what each planet is by reading the novelizations of Star Wars films — or doing some hard-core research. (For what else is the internet good? 😉 )

    I agree. Jyn Erso could have been fleshed out a bit more, especially since she was instrumental in the Rebel Alliance’s efforts to find out whether the Empire’s new super weapon could be destroyed. But, then again, maybe downplaying her role was indicative that this really was a team effort to find a solution. Each main member of the assault team was at about the same level of understated fervor (more or less).

    One aspect of the film that both my husband and I liked was the cost of war — both individually (for example, the choices each soldier makes, and having to deal with those choices; think Captain Andor in his alley encounter) and en masse (I will not say anything specific lest I give too much away). That was a bold move — probably the boldest move — Gareth Edwards made with “Rogue One”.

    I can’t wait to see this newest chapter in the Star Wars Saga a fourth time — in the coming week when I get to see it with both my daughters. 😀 I want so much to say to them: “Make sure you look for *this* or *that* at *such and such a point*,” but that would be too telling. They deserve to be totally surprised — just like I was. 🙂

    Wonderful review, Dan! Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

    Happy Holidays, and MTFBWY 🙂

  3. drush76
    December 24, 2016 at 23:02 Reply

    Actually the ramifications of this movie only lasts as far as “A New Hope”.

  4. drush76
    December 24, 2016 at 23:06 Reply

    It’s much heavier than the episodic films, presents a much more discernibly fractured universe, and asks much tougher questions. Let us know your thoughts on . . .

    I don’t know if I agree with you on this assessment. Don’t get me wrong. I enjoyed “Rogue One”. And I believe that Gareth Edwards went out of his way to make this story as tough and ambiguous as possible. But it wasn’t enough to me. I don’t feel that this movie really went all of the way. The ambiguity in this film did not strike me as ambiguous as the Prequel movies. And the galaxy did not strike me as fractured as it was portrayed in the 1999-2005 films.

    1. Dan Z & Cory Clubb
      January 21, 2017 at 08:15 Reply

      I appreciate your feedback and analysis. Has your opinion changed upon a second viewing?

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Dan Zehr is the Host and Brand Director of the Star Wars podcast Coffee With Kenobi and is the co-author of The Star Wars Book. He is a Feature Blog Contributor for, as well as a writer for IGN, and is a prominent influencer in Star Wars fandom. He is also a prolific high school educator, who teaches Literature and Composition, and has a Master's Degree in Teaching and Learning. His work combining Star Wars and education garnered him a role in the Target Rogue One: A Star Wars Story commercial, as well as feature profiles in the Chicago Tribune, Illinois State University's Statewide Standard, and the Peoria Journal Star. He has also been interviewed in Good Morning, America, the HuffPost, Forbes, and Bloomberg. He resides in Illinois with his wife and three boys.

%d bloggers like this: