Rogue One vs. The Force Awakens – Point/Counterpoint

Rogue One vs. The Force Awakens – Point/Counterpoint

In which two fans — or possibly two sides of my own brain — debate which of the new crop of movies is better: Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, or Star Wars: Episode VII The Force Awakens

POINT: Rogue One is better than The Force Awakens.

COUNTERPOINT: How can you even possibly say that?

POINT: Rogue One has a beginning, middle, and end. It introduced a host of amazing new characters into Star Wars. It perfectly transitions into A New Hope.

COUNTERPOINT: Uh, the reason that Rogue One has a beginning, middle, and end is because it’s all by itself. All the main characters die! Pretty convenient, wouldn’t you say? And what about The Force Awakens’ new characters? We have the original Big Three, plus Rey, Finn, and Poe. New baddies, too – Kylo Ren, Hux, Snoke… and a seven-foot tall murderous chrome woman!

POINT:… who gets stuffed into a trash compactor…

COUNTERPOINT: Neither here nor there. How about story? The Force Awakens is a perfect continuation of the Skywalker saga.

POINT: Is it, now? So Rey is a Skywalker?

COUNTERPOINT: We have no idea, but Kylo Ren is definitely a Skywalker. He has the hothead attitude and perfect hair to prove it. Oh, and he’s Leia’s son, so there’s that, too.

POINT: Okay, back to the point – no pun intended. I like Rogue One because Jyn is a scrappy, tough fighter who gets by any way she can. Chirrut and Baze are very interesting characters who reflect some of the older, more mystical aspects of the Force. Donnie Yen is such an exciting martial artist, too! Cassian was also a great addition to the Star Wars universe. Anger and commitment to the cause are at the heart of everything he does. Saw Gerrera, as a reachback to The Clone Wars, was fun to see. Forrest Whitaker was wonderful. And the Death Star….

COUNTERPOINT: … yep, the Death Star. Again. Granted, I don’t have room to talk about that, what with Starkiller Base and all.

POINT: Exactly. Starkiller Base was a rehash of the Death Stars – plural. At least the Death Star in Rogue One was just back in its old role, if you will.

COUNTERPOINT: I’ll give you that. Back to the new characters, though, don’t you think that Rey was a breath of fresh air? Daisy Ridley killed it!

POINT: She did, yes. I won’t deny that. I’m eager to see what becomes of her in The Last Jedi.

COUNTERPOINT: Okay, and that’s one of the reasons that The Force Awakens surpasses Rogue One. The Force Awakens’ story isn’t over yet. It’ll continue into The Last Jedi and Episode IX. There’s more to come! The saga continues!

POINT: I don’t like having to wait for it. I want the story NOW.

COUNTERPOINT: Patience is a virtue, padawan.

POINT: I also like that Luceno’s and Freed’s novelization add so much to the story. While the technical history of the Death Star wasn’t the most engaging thing I’ve read, Catalyst did help explain Galen and Krennic’s relationship and definitely set the stage for the story. We got NONE of that prior to The Force Awakens. So much of the political environment was left to our imaginations. Freed’s novelization let us know what the characters were thinking. In particular, the omniscient view added so much to Jyn and Bodhi’s characterizations.

COUNTERPOINT: So you’re admitting that the movie was NOT a stand-alone, then?

POINT: Nope – good try though! The tie-ins just improved an already fantastic story. I am firmly convinced that the movie did just fine all by itself.

COUNTERPOINT: How about the scores, though? The Force Awakens was done by the maestro himself, John Williams!

POINT: True, but you have agree that Michael Giacchino did an excellent job with the Rogue One music.

COUNTERPOINT: Yeah, but it’s not JOHN WILLIAMS… so it didn’t-


COUNTERPOINT: -feel like Star Wars to me.

POINT: Ugh! No! You said it!

COUNTERPOINT: I still liked it, but just… it wasn’t John Williams.

POINT: Well, I can’t argue that. It wasn’t John Williams. It was still fantastic, though. So much tension is built in “The Master Switch.” “Your Father Would Be Proud” is very sweet. And “Hope?!?” AMAZING! Well, maybe it’s just that I love the juxtaposition of Vader being Vader, and then the Tantive IV… and Leia… it’s just too much!

COUNTERPOINT: Don’t tell me you didn’t love “Rey’s Theme,” “March of the Resistance,” “Farewell and the Trip,” “The Jedi Steps….”

POINT: Of course I did. Shall we just agree that both of the scores are amazing?


POINT: To wrap this up, I don’t think either one of us are going to change our minds.


POINT: Can we agree that Rogue One was at least a GOOD movie?

COUNTERPOINT: I never said I didn’t love it! I just like The Force Awakens more.

POINT: Gotcha. I assume, then, that you’re looking forward to The Last Jedi?

COUNTERPOINT: Does a one-legged rathtar swim in a circle?

POINT: What?

COUNTERPOINT: Never mind. Yes, I already have my tickets!

POINT: As do I. Perhaps we should meet again after we see it, and start this all over again?

COUNTERPOINT: Let’s do it!


Until next time, thank you for reading, may the Force be with you, and remember –

This is the podcast you’re looking for!

Contact me at or on Twitter @MediocreJedi.

Powered by
Please follow and like us:

1 Comment

  1. Melinda
    November 24, 2017 at 20:54 Reply

    Very clever, MJ. 😉 🙂

    While comparing “Rogue One” to “The Force Awakens” is not comparing oranges and apples (regarding the latter pair, both are fruit, both are tasty … but that’s about where the comparison ends 😉 ), it is unfair — really — to compare RO and TFA. 😉 Had TFA been a stand-alone film, with a clearly defined beginning, middle and end, then the two sides of your brain could get away with it. 😉 In that regard, it IS like comparing oranges and apples. The two — as in RO and TFA — both are films, both happen to be in the Star Wars Saga … but that’s where the comparison ends. 😉

    I will say this — while I prefer John Williams’ sweeping musical themes throughout the Saga, M Giacchino did an impressive job scoring “Rogue One”. Not only did he complete his task in just one month (I think that was the time frame), but he kept to the musical “feel” of a Star Wars movie. 🙂 Super job he did! 🙂

    Fun read!

    MTFBWY 🙂

    p.s. just out of curiosity, do you usually find it so difficult to decide? 😉

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Mediocre Jedi is one with the Force, and the Force is with him

%d bloggers like this: