Bah Humbug! — A Star Wars Christmas Carol

Bah Humbug! — A Star Wars Christmas Carol

***The lovely Jason Palmer Padme print in this picture of the wall next to my writing space was acquired at Celebration IV.

***The lovely Jason Palmer Padme print in this picture of the wall next to my writing space was acquired at Celebration IV.

How does Obi-Wan Kenobi keep from being the GFFA’s Ebenezer Scrooge?

I don’t think about Obi-Wan Kenobi very often. Of all of the Jedi we get to know in the six film saga, his story is by far the least exciting. To me, anyway. Even though his character manages to hang around for all six films, chronologically speaking, his plain old human life is over before A New Hope’s final credits roll. He has no lone, dashing, heroic rescue onscreen, though his duels with Darth Maul and General Grievous are pretty spectacular. Funny, though, that in those two monumental battles, Obi-Wan is almost overshadowed by uber-cool light sabers. There’s no hot, young senator pining away for him like Anakin has. He’s not the go-to master and teacher in the same echelon as Yoda. He doesn’t pick up a stray slave kid at a pod race who could be the Chosen One to train as a Jedi, hinting at a rebel streak like Qui-Gon Jinn has. When we meet the stumbling old wizard who is Ben, the fact is that Luke is only interested in him because he’s a disgruntled, hormonal teenager and there’s a princess involved. Heck, he doesn’t even get a fancy schmancy purple light saber like Mace Windu does. Let’s face it, kids. Obi-Wan Kenobi is a pretty boring guy on his own merit. So what made me think of him now? Scrooge.

The Charles Dickens classic, A Christmas Carol, could apply to the sidekick of the Hero-Without-Fear by the time we meet him as “old Ben” on Tatooine. By reputation, a case forobi-wan-resized1 Obi-Wan’s likeness to the South Bend Shovel Slayer of Home Alone fame could also be made. You know…the old guy who moseys along the sidewalks with a shovel and a garbage can of salt…to “turn the bodies into mummies,” says Buzz. But I digress. The point is that on Tatooine, Ben Kenobi has a somewhat mysterious rep for being an “old hermit,” and that’s only what they will say about him on camera. A decidedly Ebenezer Scrooge comparison is fair. Old guy who doesn’t like people and keeps to himself. They don’t talk about money much in the GFFA, but I can’t see Ben spending wads of cash on anyone. And he clearly isn’t overly comfortable around scads of people.

To the best of my knowledge, Christmas doesn’t exist in the GFFA, but a long time ago in a blogosphere far, far away, I decided that Balanced Force Day does. It would be in that spirit that Dickens’ ghosts would visit Ben Kenobi, sequestered in his cave on Tatooine just before Luke reaches out to him…

The ghost of Balanced Force Day Past appears before Ben first as a Stormtrooper, but as the old wizard’s sleepy vision clears, he sees the distinct markings of a clone trooper on the figure’s white uniform. The clone hovers over Ben then speaks with a Jango-esque voice, “Obi-Wan. Come!” as it pulls Ben from the cave and opens his eyes to familiar scenes past: Qui-Gon Jinn, the only father-like figure in young Obi-Wan’s life, broken by the sinister Darth Maul; a tow-headed boy thrust onto Obi-Wan’s shoulders in the moment of his greatest grief and the responsibility for training him that he vows to his dying master; a growing fear and resentment toward his young padawan’s attraction to the stunning senator from Naboo and the sure knowledge that nothing good could come of it; the flash of light sabers, then darkness, as Count Dooku bests Obi-Wan for the last time; Obi-Wan’s heart, shredded, forcing him to destroy his best friend and brother on the shore of lava river on Mustafar; and the moment when he turns to the life of a crotchety hermit after handing his best friend’s infant son to his aunt.

“Oh, how I wish I could change these things,” thinks Obi-Wan, “helped Anakin and Padme in their time of need. Things would be so different,” and the apparition fades.

The ghost of Balanced Force Day Present menaces Obi-Wan in the form of a Tusken Raider as it pulls the old man toward the moisture farm of Owen and Beru Lars. There Obi-Wan is privy to a lunchtime conversation over blue milk, his young charge, Luke, receiving the news that he would have to stay on at the farm for another season. Obi-Wan senses the rush of the Force through Luke and knows his path must lead far, far away from this desolate place. The specter drags Obi-Wan off to a strange, moon-shaped ship where his old friend and brother, cloaked and encased in black, sits in a meditation chamber with his fists clenched, his head bowed. The Dark Aura of the Force surrounds him. Obi-Wan wants to reach out but he can’t. His blind eyes see only that it is far too late to restore the good in his friend.

“What will happen to Luke and Anakin?” Obi-Wan implores, but the Tusken Raider only bellows and fades.

Obi-Wan senses the Dark, hooded figure of the ghost of Balanced Force Day Future before he sees it, a familiar almost regal presence. Without time to think, Obi-Wan is transported to the once lush forest moon of Endor, now an Imperial stronghold. Stormtroopers march and Force lightning flares. Ewoks in armor patrol the perimeter of the Emperor’s compound, killing anyone who crosses. Obi-Wan feels a stab in his chest as the ghost leads him past an overgrown bunker.

“Wait!” he says. “I remember this place, but,” the stabbing pain throbs, “Why?”

Obi-Wan follows the ghost’s gnarled finger to stone atop a grassy mound. Etched into the stone are the words, “The End of the Rebellion and the Rebel Scum.” It is the grave of Luke Skywalker, Leia Organa, Han Solo, and Obi-Wan Kenobi, the last of the Jedi.”

“Nooooooooo!” he screams. “How can I change these things? Please, spirit! Show me the way!” but the spirit fades and Ben is returned to his cave.

The very next day, Obi-Wan “Ben” Kenobi learns of Luke’s quest to find him. I theorize that on that day Obi-Wan’s heart was infused with the strength of ten Grinches plus two, or at least the sure knowledge that he truly is Princess Leia’s only hope. Without the help of a few Dickens-esque apparitions, there would be no New Hope. Perhaps I should think of Obi-Wan more often.

Happy December, everyone! Whatever you celebrate, if you celebrate at all, I wish you peace, joy, and Balance in your life. Always.

And remember…this IS the podcast you’re looking for…

Powered by
Please follow and like us:


  1. Mike MacDonald (@MikeTarkin)
    December 14, 2014 at 08:46 Reply

    Merry Christmas to you! That was a fun take on one hand, on the other hand, YES would Ben have had this conversation with himself? I think so.

  2. Erica
    December 14, 2014 at 20:02 Reply

    Very cool X-mas Carol rendition! I think you’re right that of all the jedi Obi-wan would have the most ghosts to deal with. More even than Yoda because he was so directly involved with Anakin’s fall. However, I have always found that I really love Obi-wan. I find his story so fascinating. I see him as the quintessential Jedi, the best expression of The Old Republic Jedi system, and then he is paired with the most radical Jedi of all time. It was a crazy situation that he wasn’t equipped to deal with. Somehow I really feel for him because I know he did his best, but it was kind of doomed to fail.

    Loved this entry! So much fun and so much to think about at the same time.

  3. Pam Bruchwalski
    December 14, 2014 at 21:33 Reply

    Thank you so much for your comment, Mike! It was fun to write. Thank you, too, Erica! You know when I really started to have much more interest in Obi-Wan? When I read those young adult EU books about young Obi-Wan…I can’t think of the name of the series now, darn it (Jedi Apprentice??)! The point is that it was outside of the films that I began to find an appreciation for him. To me, he really is a bit like Scrooge, though…a man who hides his passions, and it in in hiding them that he hurts the most, unnecessary hurt that may be cured in the new order of Jedi…which I haven’t read about!

    I know that there are plenty of people who disagree with my stance on Obi-Wan, and I could be completely wrong about him. My 37 years of Star Wars fandom don’t exempt me from mistakes, that’s for sure! I just think that Obi-Wan clung to a flawed belief system, one that led to the demise of the Jedi Order. He never got the chance to wake up Christmas morning and give Tiny Tim and his family that big ol’ turkey, you know? At least not in human form. I would like to have seen that.

  4. Melinda
    December 15, 2014 at 08:22 Reply

    Pam, I loved your tale! 🙂 How creative you are. 🙂

    I do not agree with you about Obi-Wan. He is a hero … but a quiet one. One does not have to thrust one’s accomplishments out there for everyone to see. There is so much more to the wizened Jedi than meets the eye. 🙂 Look below the surface.

    I hope you’ll forgive me, but I was a bit lost when you meandered into your account of Balance Day Future. Just one possible future? Was that what you were getting at? That if Obi-Wan wasn’t born, there to help Luke, that the Rebels would have perished on Endor?

    Happy Holidays! 🙂

  5. Pam Bruchwalski
    December 22, 2014 at 09:41 Reply

    Thank you for your comment, Melinda! In the Dickens classic, the future of Tiny Tim lies in Scrooge’s bony hands. Likewise, I believe the future of the rebellion is in Obi-Wan’s as much as it is in anyone else’s. If Obi-Wan had chosen not to sacrifice himself at the hands of Darth Vader, if he had lived to the fight on Endor, then yes I believe he would have perished alongside the rebels.

    This IS my looking below the surface of Obi-Wan, and I guess I’m kind of agreeing with you. He is a hero…in his own way. And that is, perhaps, the best way to be a hero. Using the talents you’re given.

  6. Becca Benjamin
    January 4, 2015 at 18:57 Reply

    Bah Humbug, indeed! Now this is good…real good. Quite unique, loved it. Definitely gives one a fresh outlook on Obi-Wan’s perseverance and endurance.

    Hope you had a wonderful holiday season 🙂 Happy 2015!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pam is a writer, editor, mother, fangirl, and self-proclaimed geek from Pittsburgh, PA.

%d bloggers like this: